Report: German-Polish Perspectives on Ukraine Support

► Summary (→ Jump to Section)
► Foreword (→ Jump to Section)
► Introduction (→ Jump to Section)
► Download (→ Jump to Section)

The full report in English will be available shortly. The original German version can be downloaded below.

► Summary

Poland and Germany have a strong interest in ensuring that Ukraine emerges from Russia’s war of aggression as a victor and an independent state, and becomes a full member of the EU by way of a merit-based, yet proactively designed and accession process during a manageable period.

In this discussion paper, Wilfried Jilge examines the opportunities and risks of the EU accession process and, in light of Russia’s war of aggression, identifies key thematic challenges facing Ukraine’s EU accession process from which he derives specific proposals for German-Polish-Ukrainian dialogue projects.

In total, three major dialogue projects are proposed.

The first dialogue project “Key Challenges of the EU Accession Process” comprises three key areas.

I. Focus area: “Merit-based approach versus accelerated accession process”: strategic approaches and criteria for facilitating Ukraine’s accelerated accession.
II. Focus area: “The security dilemma: merit-based EU accession versus security?”: how Ukraine can be prepared for a European security architecture once the war has ended, and how it can be included in the mutual assistance obligations of the EU Treaty even prior to full membership.
III. Focus area: “Access to EU financial instruments prior to accession”: how Ukraine can secure sufficient access to EU financial instruments in the context of the EU’s next Multiannual Financial Framework (2028-2034), and how these instruments need to be structured to effectively promote social cohesion and rapid economic development.

Second dialogue project “Integration of the Ukrainian agricultural sector into the EU”: strategic approaches for the balanced application of the instruments of the EU’s Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) to build on the complementary benefits of agricultural trade between the EU and Ukraine that already exist today, and safeguard Ukraine’s position in non-European third markets and its future role as a gateway for the EU.
Integration of the agricultural sector is seen as a particular challenge and is, therefore, proposed as a stand-alone project, with the additional involvement of French experts.

Third dialogue project “EU integration as a win-win situation: learning from the model of Ukrainian resilience in wartime”: Lessons and innovations for Germany and Poland in the face of hybrid threats emanating from Russia, with a view to strengthening the resilience of the population and civil defence. This focuses on local authorities as the “Operational hubs of crisis management” within the context of decentralised cooperation between non-state actors.

In addition, two further, smaller, optional projects are proposed, which have been derived from the dialogue projects on the EU accession process and the agricultural sector respectively.

Optional project on security: “Expert dialogue on learning from Ukraine’s asymmetric naval warfare and unmanned coastal defence”: what Germany and Poland can learn from technological innovations and operational concepts for offshore and multi-layered coastal defence, for their own security along the Baltic Sea coast and the critical (port) infrastructure located there.

Optional project in the agricultural sector: “Weimar Plus Connectivity Strategy Group”: how Ukraine can be better integrated into the European “Baltic Sea–Black Sea–Aegean Sea” corridor, for instance into the “Three Seas Initiative” with regard to geo-economic connectivity and military mobility ahead of its accession.

► Foreword by Edwin Bendyk, Stefan Batory Foundation

Germany, Poland and Ukraine. In search of strategic synergies

Ukrainians are aware that they are facing another winter of difficulties with their energy and heating supplies. Nevertheless, an overwhelming majority of 77 percent of those questioned in a survey conducted by the International Institute of Sociology in Kyiv in late August/early September 2026 responded that the fight must continue should such difficulties arise. Among Kyiv residents who still remember last winter, when hundreds of thousands of people were left without heating for weeks on end, as many as 83 percent are in favour of continuing the fight. Furthermore, the downward trend in responses to the question about willingness to endure the hardships of war has reversed: in April 2026, 61 percent of those surveyed said they were prepared to endure the hardships for as long as necessary. By September, this figure had increased to 69 percent.

This is very important data. It demonstrates not only the resilience of Ukrainian society in what is now the fifth year of the war. It is also a call to action for the societies of the countries that support Ukraine. Ultimately, a just peace, security and the long-term development of Ukraine should be the outcome of this war of defence, leading the country into the EU thereafter. In view of the ongoing threat to the security not only of Ukraine but also of European states posed by Russia, the war must be brought to an end on terms that ensure both the achievement of Ukraine’s objectives and the establishment of a security framework for Europe.

Establishing such a system requires resolving a fundamental security dilemma resulting from the fear among European states – including NATO members – of being drawn into a direct war with Russia, whether in the current conflict or in the future. At the same time, the lessons learnt from the current war show that the future European security system should be established in partnership with Ukraine, which should serve as its cornerstone.

It is in the interests of Europe, and therefore also of Poland and Germany, for Ukraine to be strong and sovereign, and to have a growing economy that ensures social development and the maintenance of its defence capabilities. Poland is a spectacular example of a development success that would not have been possible without membership of the European Union. In 2004, when Poland joined the European Union, the nominal value of Poland’s GDP stood at 192 billion euros. At the end of 2025, Poland’s GDP stood at 922 billion euros. This unprecedented economic success is having an impact not only on the quality of life in Poland today, but also on the strengthening of the country’s defence capabilities, thanks to significantly greater opportunities for investment in security.

Furthermore, a key factor in Poland’s success is its fruitful economic cooperation with its largest neighbour, Germany – which is also its largest trading partner. The history of the European integration of the Central European states, Poland in particular, is an inspiring example of how we can take a similar approach to thinking about Ukraine’s future and achieve shared security by way of integration.

Wilfried Jilge has set out a number of specific proposals in this paper. He demonstrates that the most effective approach to the challenges of the future in respect of integration, development and security lies in cooperation between Germany and Poland – through joint projects with and for the benefit of Ukraine, which harness the strategic synergies between the potential of the three countries. This is not about some sort of “Triangle” comprising Berlin, Warsaw and Kyiv as a stand-alone integration project. Rather, it is about the method of identifying these strategic synergies, paving the way for the involvement of further partners in tackling specific challenges. France, for example, in respect of agriculture, or the Baltic states in respect of finding solutions for security in the Baltic Sea region.

The study “German-Polish Perspectives on Support for Ukraine” study does not, of course, provide an exhaustive list of options. Rather, it should be seen as a proposal for an approach to identifying strategic synergies that will render breaking free from the patterns that often hinder effective action possible when shaping policy towards Ukraine and planning for the post-war future. The future of not only Ukraine but also Europe depends on the ability to overcome these patterns.

The Kyiv Dialogue, the Stefan Batory Foundation and the Foundation for German-Polish Cooperation invite you to join the discussion prompted by this study. We hope that this will lead not only to proposals, but concrete measures as well.

Edwin Bendyk

Chairman of the Board of the Stefan Batory Foundation

► Introduction

Germany and Poland are among Ukraine’s most important military and civilian supporters. Both countries have a vital interest in ensuring that Ukraine emerges from Russia’s war of aggression as the victor and as an independent state, and that it becomes a full member of the EU by way of a merit-based, yet proactively designed and accession process during a forseeable period.

Ukraine’s accession to the EU: a benefit for the EU, Poland and Germany

In this paper, Ukraine’s full integration into the EU is not viewed as a burden, nor is the current support for Ukraine seen merely as an act of solidarity, but rather as a strategic investment in the EU’s future, which is in the mutual security, economic and democratic interests of the EU and its Member States, on the one hand, and Ukraine, on the other. Ukraine’s close ties with Europe are already an asset, as numerous examples spanning various (civil) sectors have been cited in a number of studies.

The benefits of Ukraine’s full membership are already becoming apparent for Poland and Germany too. The Polish Economic Institute in Warsaw has highlighted that Ukraine’s integration into the EU represents an economic benefit both for Poland and Eastern Central Europe on the one hand, and for Ukraine on the other. Between 2021 and 2024, exports from these countries (Poland, the Czech Republic, Slovakia, Hungary, Lithuania, Bulgaria and Romania) increased by 75 percent, with Polish exports to Ukraine doubling during the same period, rendering Poland the second-largest exporter of goods to Ukraine after China.

In Germany, on the other hand, the animal feed and food industry has benefited significantly from high-quality and affordable agricultural produce. However, risks should not be glossed over: in smaller businesses in the transport and agricultural sectors in Poland, there are serious concerns that competition from Ukraine’s thriving logistics sector or its large agricultural holdings could pose a threat to their very survival. However, given that this country is a neighbour of the single market and is already closely integrated with it, the solution cannot lie in refusing it membership. In fact, the opposite is true: only the full adoption of EU production conditions and agricultural standards, in conjunction with appropriate transitional arrangements, will eliminate the unfair competitive conditions that are the main cause of the risks to their livelihoods.

Poland and Germany have a strong interest in a Ukraine that is firmly rooted in the rule of law and democracy, with a participatory, transparent market economy characterised by low risks of corruption, which is best ensured by way of Kyiv’s full membership. The integration of Ukrainian institutions into the EU also means further strengthening Ukraine’s resilience in the face of Russia, which, even after the war has ended, will not cease to destabilise and undermine the country’s westward aspirations and its EU accession process via hybrid and cognitive warfare.

Even though, from a dispassionate German and Polish perspective, there are many strong arguments in favour of Ukraine’s full EU membership, the accession process is by no means a foregone conclusion. However, to provide Ukraine with effective support in tackling key challenges, there is a need, in particular in the German-Polish-Ukrainian context, for joint, confidential and expert-led dialogue forums in which civil society, think tanks, relevant civil servants and advisers to the governments of the three countries can work together to develop coordinated solutions. This discussion paper, therefore, examines the opportunities and risks associated with the EU accession process and, in light of Russia’s war of aggression, identifies key challenges facing Ukraine’s EU accession process, from which specific proposals for German-Polish-Ukrainian dialogue projects on overarching priority topics are derived.

These dialogue projects are supplemented by key tasks, guiding questions, theses, proposals and ideas developed by the author, which are aimed at stimulating discussion and help prepare the ground for a structured dialogue, without claiming to be definitive. In total, three major dialogue projects are proposed, focusing on key challenges of the EU accession process (→ 1), integration of the agricultural sector (→ 2) and learning from the societal resilience demonstrated by Ukraine during the war (→ 3). The proposals are rounded off by two smaller optional projects, which stem from the dialogue projects on the EU accession process and the agricultural sector and flesh these out by setting out specific, practice-oriented steps: a security policy “Expert Dialogue on Learning from Ukraine’s Asymmetric Naval Warfare and Unmanned Coastal Defence” (→ 1.2.1) and a “Weimar Plus Connectivity Strategy Group” (→ 2.1) to develop proposals for the deeper integration of Ukraine into the European transport corridors linking the Baltic Sea, the Black Sea and the Adriatic Sea. One of the three key areas of the dialogue project (→ 1) can also be developed as a stand-alone project, insofar as this is requested by funders or clients or proves to be appropriate in the course of further expert discussion of the paper.

This discussion paper was drawn up in close consultation with representatives of Ukrainian and Polish civil society and the expert community, some of whom have already confirmed their willingness to participate in potential projects. This paper was commissioned by Kyiv Dialogue, which co-ordinated its preparation. On the Polish side, the Stefan Batory Foundation was a close partner, supporting the author by inviting him to conferences on the subject in Poland, putting him in touch with the Polish community of experts and providing specialist guidance. Following presentations of the study in Germany, Poland and Ukraine, the Kyiv Dialogue, in collaboration with the Stefan Batory Foundation and the Foundation for German-Polish Cooperation, will discuss the projects that can be implemented and the Ukrainian partners that can be recruited for this purpose.

The “German-Polish Perspectives on Support for Ukraine in the Light of Russia’s War of Aggression and Ukraine’s EU Accession Process” study is published with financial support from the Foundation for German-Polish Cooperation (SdpZ).

Go back

Partners and Supporters